The contract situation surrounding AC Milan goalkeeper Mike Maignan is entering a decisive and increasingly tense phase. With his current deal edging closer to its expiration and no clear breakthrough in renewal talks, uncertainty has begun to dominate the narrative around one of Milan’s most important players.
For many Milan supporters, the unfolding story feels uncomfortably familiar. Just a year ago, a similar situation surrounded Theo Hernandez, whose prolonged contract negotiations eventually ended with his departure. The parallels between the two cases are now difficult to ignore, prompting Theo himself to speak out and issue what many see as a warning to the Rossoneri hierarchy.
Déjà Vu at Milan as Maignan Talks Stall
Maignan has been a cornerstone of Milan’s recent success, providing leadership, consistency, and elite performances between the posts. Yet despite his importance, negotiations over a contract extension have reportedly made little progress. As weeks turn into months, speculation has intensified, both in Italy and across Europe.
Italian media have begun framing the situation in a familiar way: suggestions that the player’s demands may be too high, questions about the club’s financial limits, and growing uncertainty over whether a resolution will arrive in time. This narrative closely mirrors what surrounded Theo Hernandez before his eventual exit.
The sense of déjà vu has not gone unnoticed by those who lived through it. From afar, Theo has watched developments around Maignan with concern, recognizing patterns that once defined his own final months in red and black.
Theo Hernandez: “I Never Wanted to Leave Milan”
Speaking to Gazzetta dello Sport, Theo Hernandez firmly rejected the idea that his departure from Milan was driven by personal ambition or unrealistic financial demands. According to the French defender, his priority was always to remain at San Siro and continue building his legacy with the club.
Theo strongly denied claims that he had pushed for an excessive salary or forced a transfer. In his view, much of what circulated in the media at the time did not reflect the reality of discussions behind closed doors.
“Never,” Theo said when asked whether he wanted to leave. “My priority was to stay. They said I was asking for an unreasonable amount for a renewal, that I was pushing for a transfer… everything was wrong.”
He revealed that internal club pressure played a decisive role in his exit. Faced with an ultimatum from senior figures within Milan, Theo found himself in an increasingly untenable position.
“The situation became very difficult,” he explained. “There were decisions made internally that left me with very limited options.”
Eventually, Theo left Milan for Al Hilal, a move that shocked many supporters but, according to the player, was not his preferred outcome.
Warning Signs in Mike Maignan’s Case
When asked directly about Maignan’s future, Theo did not hesitate to draw comparisons. He described the goalkeeper’s situation as “very similar” to his own and cautioned that unresolved negotiations could once again lead to an outcome Milan may later regret.
Theo noted that public discourse around Maignan has already begun to follow a familiar path, with suggestions that the player is demanding too much financially. Based on his experience, he believes such narratives often oversimplify complex internal dynamics.
“He has a situation similar to mine, and it didn’t end well,” Theo admitted. “These things usually go deeper than what people see from the outside.”
The former Milan defender also warned that, if talks continue to stall, Maignan could face mounting pressure from within the club—just as he once did. For Theo, this was not speculation but lived experience.
Internal Pressure and Ultimatums
One of the most striking revelations from Theo’s comments was his description of internal ultimatums. He disclosed that while many teammates wanted him to stay, a senior club figure—whose identity he chose not to reveal—told him bluntly that his position in the squad was no longer guaranteed.
“If I stayed, I was told my name would not be included in the main squad,” Theo said. “That changes everything.”
Such statements have raised eyebrows among Milan supporters, who fear a similar approach could be taken with Maignan if negotiations drag on. The idea that a key player might be pushed toward the exit rather than accommodated has become a source of anxiety around the club.
What This Means for Milan’s Future
Maignan’s situation comes at a critical moment for Milan, who are attempting to balance financial sustainability with competitiveness at the highest level. Losing a player of his caliber—particularly under circumstances that echo recent mistakes—would represent a significant setback both on and off the pitch.
Theo’s comments serve as more than a personal reflection; they function as a cautionary tale. His experience highlights the risks of prolonged negotiations, mixed messaging, and internal pressure that can alienate even the most committed players.
For Milan’s management, the message is clear: resolving Maignan’s contract swiftly and transparently could prevent history from repeating itself. Failure to do so may not only cost the club one of Europe’s top goalkeepers, but also further damage trust between players and the board.
A Familiar Crossroads
As things stand, Mike Maignan remains an AC Milan player, but uncertainty continues to cloud his future. Theo Hernandez’s intervention has added urgency to the situation, reminding everyone how quickly unresolved negotiations can spiral into irreversible decisions.
For Milan fans, the hope is that lessons have been learned. Whether the club acts on those lessons may determine if this story ends differently—or becomes another chapter in a growing list of painful departures from San Siro.
ALSO READ :
